The 9 Best Rums For Piña Coladas

There are few drinks quite as exotic and refreshing as a pina colada. In fact, the drink is so immediately iconic that there was a song written about it!

But, to spare you the suffering of having that song stuck in your mind, we’re here to show you which rums are best for use in making your own delicious pina coladas.

So which rums work best for pina coladas? Which ones create the greatest sense of taste, and yet still give the drink the exciting kick it so rightfully deserves?

If you’re fretting over which rum to use for your own pina coladas, then you should check out this list, because we are going to take a look at 9 of the best that you can buy!

The 9 Best Rums For Piña Coladas

OUR TOP PICK

Don Q Gran Reserva Anejo XO

This immense rum from the renowned Don Q is easily one of the best to use for making Pina Coladas, but it is also incredibly nice to sip on by itself!

The rum has a distinctly oaky taste, with notes of vanilla, and a slight fruity kick that makes itself apparent with the aftertaste.

This combination of flavors also blends perfectly with the taste of coconut and pineapple, as the oaky taste gives the finished pina colada a slight earthen taste that helps to make it seem all the more exotic when it touches your palette.

Don Q is also renowned for producing rums in ways that are environmentally friendly, so you can also sip on your pina coladas comfortable in the knowledge that you are helping to protect the earth!

As mentioned before, this rum is also fantastic by itself, sipped slowly on the rocks!

Also available at totalwine.com.

EDITORS CHOICE

Myers’s Rum

If you’re looking for a rum that is a little more friendly to your budget, then you cannot go wrong with Myers’s Rum.

Though it may feature a smaller price tag than many of the options on this list, it still has an immense flavor profile that allows it to stand amongst the best.

This particular rum has very chocolatey notes which means it can help to give your pina coladas an even more creamy and rich taste than ever before.

The rum itself is aged for around four years in wooden barrels, which helps to give the rum a rich and woody taste.

Also available at thewhiskyexchange.com.

BEST VALUE

BATI 2 Year Fijian White Rum

Though this particular rum does not originate from the Caribbean, it still makes for a perfect accompaniment to a great pina colada.

This particular rum is incredibly smooth and will go down a treat whether it is mixed into your next pina colada, or simply drunk as-is, with a glass of ice.

The most prominent flavors in the rum are vanilla, oak, and even banana.

The slight banana note blends so naturally with the flavors of coconut and pineapple, that it seems like this rum was made for pina coladas!

This particular rum also stands apart from the competition thanks to its clear color, which is achieved by filtering the two-year-aged rum through a coconut shell!

Also available at drizly.com.

RUNNER UP

It’s a go-to classic for a reason.

Bacardi Gold is perfect for when you want a quick and easy solution for making your own pina coladas, because it features an incredibly fair price tag, but does not sacrifice its flavor profile.

Bacardi Gold has a rich and warm mouth-feel, and its flavor profile includes things such as caramel, banana, and almond.

These tastes will meld beautifully with coconut milk and pineapple juice to elevate the exotic tastes even further!

This rum is also a little sweeter than other competing rums, so it is perfect for creating classic pina coladas!

Also available at bacardi.com.

RUNNER UP

Mount Gay Eclipse

Mount Gay is actually headed up by the immensely talented Trudiann Branker, who is able to expertly blend all of the many ingredients that go towards making this rum work.

The notes that you should expect from this particular rum are a combination of banana, vanilla, and hints of caramel.

It’s a real treat to sip on this rum yourself, as the flavors mix together beautifully. As such, you can also bet that it makes for a great mixer for pina coladas.

This hand-crafted rum is the perfect option, and it won’t cost you the Earth, too!

Also available at masterofmalt.com.

RUNNER UP

Santa Teresa 1796

If you’re willing to push the boat out a little more, then you could always spring for the slightly more expensive Santa Teresa 1796.

This amazing rum is made by blending multiple rums that have been aged for more than 35 years in bourbon barrels.

This means that the Santa Teresa 1796 rum is truly rich and full-bodied, and makes for an incredible flavor experience.

This is also the case when blending it with other elements of a classic pina colada! Take the plunge and experience this amazing drink for yourself!

Also available at thewhiskyexchange.com.

RUNNER UP

Barbancourt Estate Reserve 15 Year

The 15-year age of this particular rum is what helps to elevate it well above the rest of the competition.

The time that it has spent in the barrel has allowed it to take on some very unique flavors you won’t find elsewhere.

The flavor profile features notes such as Almond, Pear, and even Butterscotch.

If you want to experience a pina colada as you’ve never had before, then you should definitely try mixing it with this perfect rum.

Also available at wine.com.

RUNNER UP

Plantation Stiggins’ Fancy Pineapple Rum

If your favorite part of a pina colada is the pineapple flavor, or you’ve simply run out of pineapple juice for the drink, then you have to check out Plantation Stiggins’ Fancy Pineapple Rum.

If it wasn't obvious already, the major flavor note in its profile is that of pineapple!

This means that, when mixed into a perfect pina colada, this particular rum will create a drink that will whisk you away to a tropical island, surrounded by blue waters, and under the beaming sun!

Also available at drizly.com.

RUNNER UP

Don Q Coco

Similar to our last entry on this list, if you love the coconut flavors in your favorite pina coladas, then you simply have to try out this immense coconut-inspired rum.

The masters at Don Q turn their hands here to experimenting with rum to create a rum that is incredibly tropical and has a smooth mouthfeel that glides across your tongue.

The coconut taste elevates any pina colada even further! Also available at drizly.com.

The Best Rums For Piña Coladas Buying Guide

Now that you’ve seen some of the best rums on the market, you’re probably feeling ready to go ahead and grab one!

If so, make sure to check out our guide below, so that you can make the right choice with your rum!

The 9 Best Rums for Piña Coladas

Price

One of the most important things to consider whenever you buy a new bottle of rum is to consider how much it costs.

Different types and brands of rum can cost very different prices, and, as such, you will want to make sure that you are always spending the right amount.

If you are new to buying rum, it is recommended to go for a more affordable option, so that you do not spend excessive amounts.

Taste

This may sound obvious, but ensuring that your new rum tastes just right is very important!

You will want to make sure that you choose a rum that perfectly complements the flavors of the pina colada, but you may also want to choose a rum that tastes great even on its own.

Make sure to check out each rum’s individual flavor profile before you purchase.

Mouth Feel

You may also want to change your decision based on how each rum feels in the mouth.

Some rums have a more harsh mouth feel than others, and are thus more “warm” in how they feel.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can You Make A Pina Colada With Dark Rum?

Totally. You can very easily make a pina colada using dark rum, and it will lead to a more rich drink.

Is Coconut Cream The Same As Cream Of Coconut?

No. Coconut cream, unlike cream of coconut, is totally unsweetened, and is quite thick.

What Is In A Virgin Pina Colada?

A virgin pina colada is quite easy to make, as it just involves blending some pineapple juice and cream of coconut, but without adding any rum!

Mandy Winters
Latest posts by Mandy Winters (see all)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.